“Popeye the Sailor Meets Ali Baba’s Forty Thieves,” also known as “Ancient Fistory,” is a classic animated short film featuring Popeye the Sailor. Directed by Seymour Kneitel, it was released by Famous Studios in 1937. Here’s an analysis of the cartoon:

Plot Summary: In “Ancient Fistory,” Popeye tells his four nephews the story of his ancestor Hercules, who was a great hero. The cartoon is a humorous retelling of Hercules’ legendary feats, including his battles against various monsters and adversaries. The nephews, however, interject with skepticism and disbelief, leading to comical interactions.

Analysis:

1. Meta-Narrative Structure: “Ancient Fistory” employs a meta-narrative structure where Popeye narrates a story within the cartoon itself. This adds an extra layer of humor as Popeye’s nephews react to and question the events of the story. The skepticism of the nephews provides comedic commentary on the fantastical nature of Popeye’s tale.
2. Parody of Hercules: The cartoon is a parody of the Hercules myth, presenting exaggerated and comical versions of the legendary hero’s adventures. Popeye’s ancestor Hercules displays superhuman strength and faces whimsical challenges, all presented in a humorous and cartoonish manner.
3. Interaction with Nephews: The dynamic between Popeye and his nephews is central to the cartoon’s humor. The nephews’ skepticism and questioning of the story create amusing contrasts with the fantastical elements described by Popeye. The interactions contribute to the overall comedic tone.
4. Exaggerated Action: “Ancient Fistory” features exaggerated action sequences typical of Popeye cartoons. Hercules faces various adversaries, each encounter more absurd than the last. The use of fantastical elements and Popeye’s characteristic spinach power-ups add to the cartoon’s comedic and action-packed nature.
5. Animation Style: The animation in the cartoon reflects the style of Famous Studios during the Golden Age of Animation. The expressive character animations, dynamic movements, and vibrant visuals contribute to the overall charm and appeal of the cartoon.
6. Humor and Satire: The cartoon employs humor and satire to poke fun at the conventions of heroic storytelling. By presenting Hercules as a somewhat bumbling and comically inept character, the cartoon subverts traditional hero tropes, providing a lighthearted and entertaining take on mythology.
7. Musical Accompaniment: As with many classic cartoons, the musical score enhances the viewing experience. The soundtrack complements the on-screen action, emphasizing key moments and contributing to the overall comedic atmosphere.
8. Cultural Impact: “Ancient Fistory” is part of the Popeye series and has contributed to the enduring popularity of the character. Its playful approach to mythology and humor has left a lasting impact on animation history.

Overall, “Popeye the Sailor Meets Ali Baba’s Forty Thieves” (Ancient Fistory) is a classic animated short that combines humor, action, and meta-narrative elements. It remains a beloved and entertaining piece of animation history within the larger Popeye series.